Court Ruling No Longer Requires Surgery for Changing Gender on Birth Certificates

A federal court in Tucson has ruled that Arizona can no longer require transgender individuals to undergo surgery to change the gender listed on their birth certificates.

The decision, issued Tuesday by a U.S. District Court, granted a permanent injunction against the state’s previous policy. The court found that the surgery requirement violated the Equal Protection and Due Process Clauses of the Fourteenth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.

The lawsuit was brought by a group of transgender individuals born in Arizona who sought to update the gender marker on their birth certificates. They were represented by the National Center for Lesbian Rights (NCLR), along with the law firms Cooley LLP and Osborn Maledon, PA.

“We are thrilled that the Arizona Department of Health Services will be permanently enjoined from enforcing this irrational and overly burdensome requirement, and Plaintiffs will be able to amend their birth certificates to reflect who they are,” expressed Rachel Berg, NCLR Staff Attorney. 

Previous Obstacles

Supporters of the decision say the prior requirement created obstacles for transgender individuals, especially young people who typically do not undergo surgery. 

They argue that requiring surgery forces people to reveal their transgender status in situations where they would otherwise choose not to, potentially exposing them to harm or discrimination.

Transgender youth were effectively barred from updating their documents under the old policy. Birth certificates significantly impact many aspects of daily life, including school records and registration for activities such as sports or camps.

Arizona’s Department of Health Services, which manages vital records, will no longer be allowed to enforce the surgical requirement following the court’s decision.

The ruling applies to all transgender individuals born in Arizona and marks a significant legal development in how gender markers are handled on official state documents.